- Banking Sector Needs Research that Can Challenge Established Practice — Dr Mumuni
The success of the National Banking College’s new journal will not be measured by its launch, but by whether the research it publishes changes decisions inside banks and financial institutions, Bank of Ghana First Deputy Governor Dr Zakari Mumuni has said.
Speaking at the journal’s launch in Accra on November 13, Dr Mumuni urged the College to build a publication that preserves institutional knowledge, invites rigorous debate and connects academic research to the practical challenges facing the banking industry.
“A maiden edition is easy to celebrate,” he said. “The real test is what happens after today.”
His challenge goes to the heart of a persistent problem in complex institutions: experience is gained, but the lessons are not always recorded or shared.
A risk officer may identify a control weakness, a supervisor may find a more effective approach, or a researcher may produce evidence that contradicts established practice.
If that knowledge remains with individuals or within one institution, others may repeat the same mistakes.
Dr Mumuni said a credible journal could help turn such experience into shared institutional memory. Its value, he argued, would lie not simply in publishing articles, but in helping banking professionals and researchers learn from evidence and apply it to real decisions.
The need for that exchange is growing as banks manage more products and technologies, respond to changing customer expectations and meet evolving regulatory demands. In that environment, experience alone is not enough, he said.
It must be supported by research, reflection and an honest assessment of what works and what does not.
The address offered the new publication both encouragement and a warning. Launching a journal is an achievement; sustaining its credibility is the greater responsibility.
Dr Mumuni said the College must be willing to publish well-reasoned arguments that challenge conventional thinking, provided they are grounded in evidence.
That requires rigorous peer review, editorial independence and intellectual honesty. “Independence of thought is not simply a principle to declare,” he said. “It is a discipline to defend, issue after issue.”
The emphasis on independence is significant for a publication operating in a sector where regulators, banks and other institutions may have different views on policy, risk and performance.
A journal that avoids difficult subjects to preserve institutional comfort may attract little serious engagement. One that publishes carefully examined disagreements can help improve the quality of decision-making.
The challenge, therefore, is not simply to produce a regular publication. It is to create the conditions under which contributors can discuss failures, weaknesses and contested policies without lowering standards of evidence or fairness.
For the journal to earn confidence, its editorial process will have to demonstrate that critical analysis is welcome and that conclusions are tested rather than assumed.
Dr Mumuni said credibility would not be established by a successful first edition. It would have to be earned through consistency, quality and a willingness to confront difficult questions.
That places a long-term responsibility on the College’s leadership and editorial team: maintaining standards even when the subject matter is uncomfortable or the findings challenge prevailing assumptions.
He also placed responsibility on the wider banking community. Banks and financial institutions, he said, should treat the journal as an invitation to share their experience, including the difficult lessons.
A publication’s usefulness depends partly on the honesty of its contributors. Institutions that share only polished success stories may deprive the sector of the practical insight needed to avoid repeated errors.
Regulatory bodies also have a role. Dr Mumuni said sound policy is strengthened when ideas are tested through evidence and improved through debate, rather than protected by silence.
That proposition is especially relevant where regulation affects the conduct of institutions, the management of risk and the confidence of customers. Research and open discussion can reveal whether a policy is working as intended, where implementation is falling short and what adjustments may be needed.
Academics and students, meanwhile, must bring scholarship closer to practice. Dr Mumuni urged them to ask questions that matter to institutions and to produce research that helps practitioners understand problems and make better decisions.
The connection should run both ways: banks can offer researchers practical problems and evidence, while research can provide institutions with new ways to interpret risks and assess solutions.
The address presented the journal as a possible bridge between professional experience and academic inquiry. That bridge will only hold if the publication is useful to both sides.
Research that is rigorous but disconnected from the decisions facing institutions may struggle to influence practice. Practitioner commentary that is vivid but unsupported by evidence may not withstand scrutiny.
The test will be whether articles can meet both demands: analytical discipline and practical relevance.
Dr Mumuni set a clear measure of impact. If someone changes a decision, improves a model or questions a long-held assumption because of something published in the journal, then it will have fulfilled its purpose.
That standard shifts attention from the number of copies produced or the ceremony surrounding the launch to the effect of the work on institutional behaviour.
It is a demanding measure because changes in practice can be difficult to attribute to a single article. Yet it gives the journal a direction: publish work that can influence how institutions assess evidence, design controls, respond to customers and make policy.
The launch also raises a broader question for the banking sector: how does it ensure that lessons survive staff changes and organisational boundaries? Institutions often invest in systems, training and compliance.
But those investments can lose value when knowledge is not documented, examined and passed on. A journal cannot solve that problem alone, but it can create a public record of ideas and experience that is available beyond the institution where it originated.
The publication’s long-term relevance will depend on whether it can establish a dependable rhythm of contribution and scrutiny. Will there be a second edition, a tenth, and will each earn the confidence of its readers?
Dr Mumuni left those questions open, while making clear that the maiden edition is only a beginning.
His call was ultimately for more than a journal. It was a call for a banking culture that values evidence, learns from mistakes and allows ideas to be challenged.
The publication can preserve knowledge, he said, but its purpose will be realised only when knowledge moves beyond the page and into practice.
